There are 3 separate entities lower eyelid bags, festoons and malar bags.
Lower eyelid bags refers to protruding fat or redundant muscle in the lower eyelid itself above the level of the bone rim under the eye.
Lower Eyelid Bags
Festoons refers to redundant folds of skin with or without muscle in the lower eyelid.
Malar pouches, bags or saddlebags are a prominence below the level of the bone rim under the eye due some combination of swelling or edema, drooping eyelid muscle (orbicualris oculi muscle) and fat under the muscle herniating through the muscle. The lower edge of the malar bags is defined or limited by the zygomatico-cutaneous ligament which has also been called the malar septum.
This ligament stops the discoloration of a black eye from spreading down into the cheeks. There is a lot of misinformation on the web regarding malar bags, even on online question boards answered by surgeons. Some people call the bags malar crescent.
The presence of malar bags can be related to previous eyelid or nose surgery independent of who your surgeon was, a complication of dermal filler injections that block normal lymphatic flow, the aging process, genetics, allergies, sinus infections, lack of sleep, water retention (related to menses, kidney insufficiency etc.), liver cirrhosis or thyroid conditions (hypo or hyperthyroidism). The chances of them appearing after dermal filler injection is reduced if smaller beads of filler are placed closer to the underlying bone and aggressive massage of the area is avoided. I get them temporarily when my allergies act up and I lose sleep.
The acute onset of malar bags such as those seen after eyelid surgery is best treated with anti-inflammatory steroids with or without diuretics and sleeping with 2 pillows under your head. Those related to allergies should first be treated with antihistamines and avoidance of inciting allergens. The injection of 20 units of Vitrase (hyaluronidase) will quickly resolve malar bags caused by injection of a hyaluronate like Restylane or Juvederm. Chronic malar bags require a medical workup to assess for one of the causes listed. That involves blood tests such as complete blood count with differential, erythrocyte sedimentation rate, serum protein electrophoresis, cryoglobulin and cryofibrinogen testing, rheumatoid factor, antinuclear antibodies, thyroid levels and liver or kidney function blood tests. A history and physical examination will inform your doctor which if any of these tests would be required..
For chronic malar bags where a medical condition is not present or has been controlled through medications surgery can be helpful. Superficial liposuction (with the cannula holes facing away from the skin) of these malar bags via a small incision near the outer corner of the eye was first described in 1984. More recently this same liposuction via an incision at the nostril rim-cheek crease and suture elevation of the muscle to the temple muscles was described.
This is a patient in whom I sutured the eyelid protruding fat to the deep cheek fat and liposuctioned fat in the malar bag between the skin and the eyelid-cheek muscle. No skin was removed. A similar though usually temporary result can be achieved using dermal filler injections directly over the ligament.
This is a patient who underwent malar bag liposuction and muscle suture elevation elsewhere.
Nasojugal Crease – Tear Trough Deformity
Aaron Stone MD – Plastic Surgeon Los Angeles
Aaron Stone MD – twitter
Hi Dr Stone, I've been getting malar bags on and off for over a year now. I've had them now for weeks they won't go away it seems this time.
I have blood work done with regular check ups and nothing out of the ordinary I'm at a loss what's causing them, the right side is more swollen than the left.
Going to see my Dr next week to try to find a cause but not optimistic with previous bloodwork ok while I've been having this problem.
The lady on your photo is a good example of my problem I have no under eye bags just the malar ones.
What kind of price range was her treatment and how long is the recovery time for that procedure?
Also I've read laser therapy may work for this problem, does that last or is that a temporary measure with this?
I have lost a substantial amount of weight over the past twelve months 50lb. could that be a reason?
Given your history of recurrent malar bags I would not recommend surgery as there is more likely something else going on. Surgery should be reserved for those who have consistent constant malar bags because recurrent malar bags are better treated medically i.e. non-surgically. The actual treatment would depend on the cause and your internist not finding the cause does not mean there is no medical reason for the problem. It just means that it has not as yet been found. Never having seen or examined you when the problem is worse and better I cannot say much more.
I just noticed that I've developed festoons over the past few months (also coinciding with a pounding headache in between my eyes).
Thanks to your very well written article that includes the wide range of causes for festoons, I suspect allergies or sinus issues.
Thank so much for writing an informative article that is not alarmist – hard to find that on the Internet these days! Very grateful.
Hi Dr. Stone,
I developed malar bags a week ago and I suspected they were due to my allergies, but even after my allergies are gone the bags are still persisting. Will these bags eventually go away on their own or should I start looking into surgery? Thanks!
The soft tissue changes that take place due to allergies do not resolve as quickly as the allergies themselves when you begin taking allergy medications. The medications may immediately stop the allergic reactions but it can take weeks or months before the soft tissues return to baseline or reach a new baseline.
Have you performed this procedure in any other patients? I am 25 years old and been bothered by severe malar bags all my life. I believe they are just genetic. I’ve tried dietary changes as well as supplements to no avail. They fluctuate maybe a little, but mostly they’re just there.
Yes I have. The male patient in the before and after photos was not much older than you.